A·S·R  Adjudicated Settlement Record · Worked examples

Worked examples: what the ASR found, and what was decided later

Each example restates a claim as it stood when it was made, before anyone ruled on it, and checks it against the terms it had to meet. The same assessment runs in every case; the examples are grouped by where it is used. They are illustrations of the method, not a measure of accuracy.

What the ASR found, and what was decided later

Eleven real claims, each restated as it stood when the claim was made and checked against its terms. The right-hand columns show what a court, an exchange or a market vote decided afterwards.

ClaimThe ASR, at the time of the claimDecided laterHow they compare
Placefirst: pay less and payment noticesConstruction, UKMeetsCourt: both notices validSame
Lapp: an application with no payer’s noticeConstruction, UKMeets; the notified sum followsCourt: the sum applied for is payableSame
Fortis: the certificateLetter of creditDoes not meetCourt: the certificate was discrepantSame
Fortis: returning the documentsLetter of creditNot yet shown: held for a personCourt implied a “reasonable promptness” ruleDifferent on purpose: the ASR does not add a rule the terms do not contain
Padilla v Mederos (UFC 327)Prediction market, KalshiMeetsKalshi paid YesSame
Michigan v Western Michigan: the final resultPrediction market, KalshiMeetsMichigan won 13–12Same
Western Michigan: settled at 0:00 during a reviewPrediction market, KalshiNo finding: referredKalshi reversed the payoutThe ASR did not support the payout that was reversed
TikTok ban in the USPrediction market, PolymarketMeets, review requiredVote: YesSame
US–Ukraine minerals dealPrediction market, PolymarketNot shown: records conflict, referredVote: YesLeft to a person: official records pointed both ways
Strategy bitcoin salePrediction market, PolymarketMeetsVote: NoDifferent. The listed rules state no publication deadline; the ASR read none in
Zelenskyy suitPrediction market, PolymarketMeetsVote: NoDifferent. The listed rules set no tailoring standard; the ASR applied none

The cases were chosen because they were disputed, so this is not an accuracy rate. It shows how the ASR behaves: it follows the terms as written, refers conflicts to a person, and does not add rules. The Kalshi cases are published on Event Contracts, which is built on the ASR. All findings are stated under ASR Methodology 1.12.

Questions the ASR answers, with these cases →

Prediction-market settlement

Markets settled by token vote, assessed by hand using the ASR methodology, and by the ASR itself, at the time of the settlement claim.

Four disputed prediction markets: Strategy, the US–Ukraine minerals deal, the Zelenskyy suit, the TikTok banPrediction markets · settled by token vote · assessed by hand and by the ASR at the time of the claim, with the term a rules review would flag Three Kalshi markets: Padilla v Mederos, and Western Michigan v Michigan (two markets)Prediction markets · settled by the exchange · published on Event Contracts, which is built on the ASR

Construction payment claims

Published judgments, run through the ASR at the time of the claim and compared with what the court later decided.

Placefirst: Meets the contract terms assessedConstruction · UK interim payment notices · the court later: The court held that both the pay less notice and the payment notice were valid, so the sum payable was the… Lapp: Meets the contract terms assessedConstruction · statutory payment terms (the Scheme) · the court later: The court held that the application was valid. It set out the value of the work and the payments already…

Trade finance

Published judgments, run through the ASR at the time of the claim and compared with what the court later decided.

Fortis: the certificate: Does not meet the contract terms assessedTrade finance · documentary credit under UCP 600 · the court later: The court held that the certificate was discrepant. "At our cost" meant the beneficiary's cost, but the… Fortis: returning the documents: Not yet shown to meet — heldTrade finance · documentary credit under UCP 600 · the court later: The court held that the bank, having said it was returning the documents, had to do so with reasonable…

Procurement and commodity buying

Illustrative scenario, not a published case: a hypothetical transaction you can run yourself in the ASR. It has no court or market outcome to compare against.

Maize moisture: one lab sample against a 200-tonne delivery (illustrative)Procurement · quality and acceptance terms · opens the sample in the ASR so you can issue the report yourself

Check your own claim